Now that the CPAN module sealed.pm has stabilized at v7 after a year of solid real world live mod_perl 2 + ithread hosting , I think it's time to step back and ask exactly *why* this feature - first offered to p5p in 2001 by Doug MacEachern, wasn't ever incorporated into the core feature set of the language. For background, see

https://iconoclasts.blog/joe/perl7-sealed-lexicals

Instead of "it" being a technical issue at stake, it seems clear that the reason Doug's patch was rejected was more of a social problem. The Language Design Weenies in the Damian Conway Personality Cult at the time didn't *want* this feature, since only Dylan had it, and Python was never going to get it. So it was rejected outright.

Sadly, that attitude still is pervasive in the upper echelons of the community, but I think the community is better served by breaking out this functionality into a subroutine attribute that only operates on typed lexicals, which otherwise serve no useful purpose.

What do you think? Have you tried sealed.pm out in your codebase yet?

submitted by /u/joesuf4
[link] [comments]